Get ready for a Carabao Cup showdown that’s sparking debates and raising eyebrows! Newcastle United is about to face their second 'cup-tied' player in the semi-final against Manchester City, and it’s stirring up controversy. But here’s where it gets even more intriguing: Marc Guehi, fresh from a £20 million move to the Etihad, could line up against the Magpies in next month’s second leg. Sound familiar? It’s déjà vu for Newcastle, who already faced Antoine Semenyo in the first leg—a player who had previously featured for Bournemouth this season. And this is the part most people miss: thanks to a recent rule change, players can now appear for two clubs in the EFL Cup, scrapping the old 'cup-tied' tradition.
Is this rule change fair, or does it tilt the playing field? When asked about it, Newcastle manager Eddie Howe kept it professional: 'The rules are the rules. I can’t focus on that too much.' Meanwhile, Pep Guardiola brushed off concerns about Semenyo’s performance, emphasizing long-term potential over short-term results. 'He’s here for four or five years,' Guardiola said. 'I judge on that, not two games.'
Crystal Palace manager Oliver Glasner had nothing but praise for Guehi, who’s leaving the club after a stellar showing this season. 'Everyone wanted Marc to stay forever,' Glasner said. 'He’s shown 100% commitment to the team, and I wish him the best in his bright future.'
But here’s the burning question: Does this rule change favor big clubs like Man City, or does it level the playing field for all? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below! And while you’re at it, don’t miss out on the latest Newcastle United updates. Follow us on Facebook, join our WhatsApp group, subscribe to our newsletter, or tune into our Everything is Black and White podcast for expert analysis. This semi-final is just heating up—and you won’t want to miss a moment!
